Category talk:Skills Which Are Automatically Hardcore Permed

Er, this is mostly redundant to Skills Obtained From Single-Use Items--Toffile 03:05, 9 December 2009 (UTC)

They don't quite mean the same the thing. With that said, all these skill categories could definately be renamed to be much less verbose. --Lordebon 03:55, 9 December 2009 (UTC)

There really aren't enough skills to merit a sub-category, and we already list those ones that are auto-permed on another page.--Toffile 03:58, 9 December 2009 (UTC)

{{Skill}} automatically categorizes skills in permable / not permable, but technically (for example) Summon Love Song is not permable (when you are ascending you can not perm it), but it makes itself hardcore permanent upon acquiring. Well that was my thinking when I just modified the template to include the auto hardcore perm category using the same variable as perm/non-perm, as skill is either perm/non/auto. But I've been wrong before :D. But I do hate these category names. How did "Permable Skills" ("Unpermable Skills"?, "Automatically Permed Skills"?) not be thought of before "Skills Which Can Be Permed"? I also noticed the {{skill}} template wasn't locked, and so the autocat'ing and the cats was added/created by a non-admin, not that there is anything specifically wrong with that. So I don't know how much it was discussed, and the new autocat'ing in the template didn't properly not categorize the example on the template itself, or the example in the standards, etc. But that has been fixed now. At least if the categories are renamed, they can be altered in the template and everything will categorize itself properly. --JRSiebz (☎|§|‡) 04:16, 9 December 2009 (UTC)

The names are exactly what I was referring to. And in my eyes, a category (even if it's not exactly full) is preferable to a manual listing like the other page. My suggestions would be to rename the categories along the lines of what you've said), but keep the differentiation between permable and auto-HC perm'd, since there are a few non-Mr. Store skills that behave that way.