A KoL Wiki talk:Established Standards/archive: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 04:09, 27 November 2005

Just listed what's missing, so I/we don't forget! --JRSiebz (☎|§) 21:27, 26 November 2005 (Central Standard Time)

And maybe established guidelines for the following besides the creation help at Help:Contents

Clan Pages
- When I looked at those in Proposed Standards, I really wasn't sure if that warranted a standard for the bulk of wiki editors, or if that was just a stylish thing to put in your player page. As for the larger issue of clan pages, I really don't have any standards to go by. I mean, some are clones of Trog Dor's stuff, and the rest are really just whatever the relevant people want to do with them. They mostly seem more like vanity pages than informational pages. Which brings me to my next commnet... --Alpaca 22:09, 26 November 2005 (Central Standard Time)
Player Pages
- There's a rather large, unresolved discussion going on about this, and so I really don't have any guidelines. I suppose we could make a note about a few obvious things, like that you shouldn't use this as a freewebs site, or that you shouldn't be some other sort of obnoxious bandwidth vampire. I guess we do need a set of guidelines for vanity pages in general. Hmm.... --Alpaca 22:09, 26 November 2005 (Central Standard Time)

@@ Line 4: / Line 4: @@
 And maybe established guidelines for the following besides the creation help at  [[Help:Contents]]
 *Clan Pages
+**When I looked at those in [[Proposed Standards]], I really wasn't sure if that warranted a standard for the bulk of wiki editors, or if that was just a stylish thing to put in your player page. As for the larger issue of clan pages, I really don't have any standards to go by. I mean, some are clones of Trog Dor's stuff, and the rest are really just whatever the relevant people want to do with them. They mostly seem more like vanity pages than informational pages. Which brings me to my next commnet... --[[User:Alpaca|<font color="green">Alpaca</font>]] 22:09, 26 November 2005 (Central Standard Time)
 *Player Pages
+**There's a rather large, unresolved [[Discussion#Vanity_.26_Collector_Pages|discussion]] going on about this, and so I really don't have any guidelines. I suppose we could make a note about a few obvious things, like that you shouldn't use this as a freewebs site, or that you shouldn't be some other sort of obnoxious bandwidth vampire. I guess we ''do'' need a set of guidelines for vanity pages in general. [[Proposed Standards#Vanity Pages|Hmm....]] --[[User:Alpaca|<font color="green">Alpaca</font>]] 22:09, 26 November 2005 (Central Standard Time)