Talk:Meatsmithing
This page is dedicated to finding the meatsmithing recipes that use the revamped smithing mechanics.
New Testing Matrix (Recipes of August 15th 2006)
Items marked ?? need confirmation.
Newly Newly smithable (including unmatched smithables of 8/1):
| Newly Newly smithable |
|---|
| goat beard |
| carob chunks |
| goat cheese |
| meat vortex |
| scrumptious reagent |
| wad of tofu |
| Knob Goblin firecracker |
| hot wing |
| ghuol guolash |
| patchouli incense stick |
| Tasty Fun Good rice candy |
| glowing red eye |
| chrome sword |
| chrome staff |
| chrome crossbow |
| linoleum sword |
| linoleum staff |
| linoleum crossbow |
| asbestos sword |
| asbestos staff |
| asbestos crossbow |
| powders/nuggets/wads (except twinkly powders and sleaze wad) |
Forum post here -- let's keep discussion of the 8/15 weapons in this section. --DirkDiggler 20:46, 15 August 2006 (CDT)
Old Testing Matrix (Recipes of August 1st 2006)
It looks like each basic packaging weapon + the starch weapons matches with exactly one newly-smithable. I'm guessing that the nugget/wad combinations may require super-advanced.--DirkDiggler 01:31, 2 August 2006 (CDT)
Newly smithable:
| Newly smithable |
|---|
| baseball |
| sonar-in-a-biscuit |
| razor-sharp can lid |
| long skinny balloon |
| dry noodles |
| White Citadel burger |
| bowl of cottage cheese |
| spices |
| pine tar |
| poutine |
| meat engine |
| forest tears |
| bling-bling |
| Knob Goblin firecracker |
| powders/nuggets/wads (except twinkly powders, and sleaze wad) |
Would someone with Super-advanced please check the elemental nuggets and wads against the (asbestos,chrome,linoleum) (sword,staff,bow) smithables? --DirkDiggler 02:34, 2 August 2006 (CDT)
testing for remaining recipies
So remaining on the recipies unfound list: Knob Goblin firecracker, spooky powder, stench powder, (useless powder?) and all smithable nuggests and wads. There also appear to be no gaps in the item number table, so I suspect it is possible that other recipies haven't been implemented yet, or require advanced skills.Teffania
| component | spooky powder | sleaze powder | stench powder | knob goblin firecracker | elemental nuggets | elemental wads | tester | skills |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| basic meat fez | no | no | no | Teffania Anmbia |
none none | |||
| basic meat pants | no | no | no | no | Teffania StrawberryLetter23 | none Armorcraftiness | ||
| basic meat helmet | no | no | no | no | Teffania StrawberryLetter23 | none Armorcraftiness | ||
| meaty helmet turtle | no | no | no | no | StrawberryLetter23 | Armorcraftiness | ||
| helmet turtle | no | no | no | StrawberryLetter23 | Armorcraftiness | |||
| basic meat skirt | no | no | no | Teffania Anmbia |
none<none> | |||
| buckler buckle | no | no | no | no | Teffania StrawberryLetter23 | none Armorcraftiness | ||
| whip kit | no | no | no | no | Teffania StrawberryLetter23 | none Armorcraftiness | ||
| spork | no | no | no | Teffania | none | |||
| styrofoam weapons | no | no | no | Teffania | none | |||
| cardboard weapons | no | no | no | Teffania | none | |||
| bubblewrap weapons | no | no | no | Teffania | none | |||
| basic meat weapons | no | no | no | no | Teffania StrawberryLetter23 | none Armorcraftiness | ||
| dripping meat weapons | no | |||||||
| starchy weapons | no | |||||||
| meat stack | no | no | no | no | StrawberryLetter23 | Armorcraftiness | ||
| dense meat stack | no | no | no | StrawberryLetter23 | Armorcraftiness | |||
| asbestos meat stack | no | |||||||
| chrome meat stack | no | no | ||||||
| linoleum meat stack | no | no | ||||||
| asbestos sword hilt | no | |||||||
| chrome sword hilt | no | |||||||
| linoleum sword hilt | no | |||||||
| asbestos crossbow string | no | |||||||
| chrome crossbow string | no | |||||||
| linoleum crossbow string | no | |||||||
| asbestos stick | no | |||||||
| chrome stick | no | |||||||
| linoleum stick | no |
Added the stench powder column--StrawberryLetter23 16:16, 2 August 2006 (CDT)
Older Testing Matrix (Recipes of July 20ish 2006)
Since all items except wrapping paper have now been tested, what is most needed is checking the ores against the rest of the items looking for new combinations that are smithable.
Comments
Has anybody tried sending the ores with a package of some kind? What about meat pasting them with boxes? Just a few thoughts.--Locutus 16:30, 22 July 2006 (CDT)
I've tried meat pasting them to eachother and or boxes. No results. What about armorcraftiness though, or perhaps the level 15 seal clubber skill. --Ijukamajak 21:36, 22 July 2006 (AST)
I can't test this -- I lack the req. skill -- but the crimbo parts recently started dropping from one monster in the Citadel quest area. Have Felt, Googly Eye, etc. been tested? They're not on the above table.--DirkDiggler 20:12, 22 July 2006 (CDT)
- That's because they aren't meatsmithing components - they're toymaking components. --Quietust 20:21, 22 July 2006 (CDT)
Bunch of new smithable items - baseballs, razor sharp can lids, sonar-in-a-biscuit, dry noodles, White Citadel burgers --StrawberryLetter23
Also: long skinny balloon, bowl of cottage cheese, spices, powders/nuggets/wads (except twinkly powders), pine tar, poutine, meat engine (see forums post
Knob goblin firecracker smithable. Have no idea what for.--Weirdguy 03:04, 2 August 2006 (CDT)
- Tried with almost every meatsmithing item available (Save for weird stuff like event specific gear like the petrified time, fake grass, and wrapping paper, and freaky things I just don't have like Ketchup and raspberries) and nothing at all appears to work with the firecracker as of yet, WITH Super-Advanced and Armorcraftiness.--Katarani 05:02, 3 August 2006 (CDT)
bigger stick, sinewy crossbow string, and sturdy sword hilt are smithable with dense meat stacks. the sword can be smithed with scrumptious regeants--Citizenofloathing 19:20, 15 August 2006 (CDT)
The Super Magic Power Sword X can be made from scratch without Super-Advanced Meatsmithing.--LittleMatty 04:51, 16 August 2006 (CDT)
If Innabox (the smith in Degrassi Knoll) can't smith it, does that confirm that the item needs Super-Advanced Meatsmithing?--Aemeth 02:09, 17 August 2006 (CDT)
Sectioning
- The Super-Advanced Meatsmithing section should be at the Super-Advanced Meatsmithing page, not here, and the same goes for Armorcraftiness and its section.--Dehstil (t|c) 21:28, 17 August 2006 (CDT)
Discussion moved from Talk:Packaging weapons
When the recipes get found out, this page will need to be deleted. I don't really like the idea of this redirect. --Someone Else 07:46, 20 July 2006 (CDT)
- There is a link on the forums to here. This needs to exist for simplicity's sake.--SomeStranger (t|c) 08:49, 20 July 2006 (CDT)
Cleaning up tables
I threw together some new table formats. They take up a lot less space than the current format. Stat requirements are listed per weapon, I couldn't think of an effective way of showing that swords/staffs required muscle, but crossbows required moxie.
Table for tier 2 basic meat weapons:
 bubblewrap ore Stat +3 Power: 60 |
 cardboard ore Stat +3 Melee Damage +3 Power: 60 |
 styrofoam ore Stat +3 +3 to Monster Level Power: 60 |
 dry noodles Stat +3 Power: 40 |
 ketchup or catsup Stat +2 Power: 50 |
 stone of eXtreme power Stat +7 Power: 60 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 basic meat sword Muscle +x |
bubblewrap sword Moxie +2 Req: 15 Muscle |
cardboard sword Req: 15 Muscle |
styrofoam sword Req: 15 Muscle |
starchy sword Req: 5 Muscle |
dripping meat sword Req: 10 Muscle |
eXtreme meat sword Req: 15 Muscle |
 basic meat staff Mysticality +x |
bubblewrap staff Muscle +2 Req: 15 Muscle |
cardboard staff Req: 15 Muscle |
styrofoam staff Req: 15 Muscle |
starchy staff Req: 5 Muscle |
dripping meat staff Req: 10 Muscle |
eXtreme meat sword Req: 15 Muscle |
 basic meat crossbow Moxie +x |
bubblewrap crossbow Mysticality +2 Req: 15 Moxie |
cardboard crossbow Req: 15 Moxie |
styrofoam crossbow Req: 15 Moxie |
starchy crossbow Req: 5 Moxie |
dripping meat crossbow Req: 10 Moxie |
eXtreme meat crossbow Req: 15 Moxie |
Table for tier 2 dense meat weapons:
 scrumptious reagent Stat +4 Power: 80 |
 secret blend of herbs and spices Stat +5 Power: 70 | |
|---|---|---|
 dense meat sword Muscle +x |
savory sword Req: 25 Muscle |
Kentucky-fried meat sword Req: 20 Muscle |
 dense meat staff Mysticality +x |
savory staff Req: 25 Muscle |
Kentucky-fried meat staff Req: 20 Muscle |
 dense meat crossbow Moxie +x |
savory crossbow Req: 25 Moxie |
Kentucky-fried meat crossbow Req: 20 Moxie |
Table for sticky meat pants/skirt/kilt (this might be overkill):
 really really sticky spider web Req: 7 Moxie Power: 45 Moxie +3 | |
|---|---|
 basic meat pants |
sticky meat pants |
 basic meat skirt |
sticky meat skirt |
basic meat kilt |
sticky meat kilt |
How do these look? --TechSmurf 00:42, 25 April 2007 (CDT)
New Turtles
There are a batch of new turtles that are smithable into weapons. They apparently don't require Armorcraftiness. So I'm wondering how we're going to incorporate them into the table.
--MaskedLihc 01:10, 9 June 2009 (UTC)
Incorrect statement
Following a literal interpretation of the text immediately below the section entitled Basic Meatsmithing, Tier 3 got me stuck. The following comments on the KoL forums got me unstuck:
So this statement is wrong:
All tier 2 improved basic meat weapons can be further enhanced with the following items to create weapons with even more capabilities.
I went to change it, but at this point I only know that it is wrong. As of yet, I don't exactly know what to write to make a statement like that correct, so I posted nothing.
Anyone able to fix that statement?
--Bar 20:06, 14 March 2011 (UTC)
